Singular antecedents require singular pronouns; plural antecedents require plural pronouns.
Indefinite pronouns like "everyone", "anybody", and "each" are grammatically singular in standard formal grammar. Singular "they" is recognized for gender-unspecified singular antecedents by modern style guides.
"Every employee must submit their annual review before Friday."
Modern formal English widely adopts singular "their" to refer smoothly to gender-neutral individuals.
"Neither of the female candidates withdrew her application."
Traditional singular agreement matching singular distributive pronoun "Neither".
Shifting abruptly between "their" and "his or her" creates clumsy pronoun dissonance.
Academic essays, legal documents, professional communications, and style compliance.
Pronouns replace nouns and shift forms depending on whether they serve as the subject, object, or possessor.
Subjects and verbs must match in grammatical number (singular with singular, plural with plural).